The following Written Reasons for Decisions have been handed down this week. Links to the full text of the Decisions at the AustLII website are provided.
This page is updated each weekday and is current to 19 December 2014.
You can also subscribe to the AAT Bulletin - a weekly publication containing a list of recent AAT decisions and information relating to appeals against AAT decisions. Read recent Bulletin issues.
Naboush and Child Support Registrar  AATA 930; 15/12/2014; The Hon B Tamberlin QC, Deputy President
Departure prohibition order – child support liability not wholly discharged – no satisfactory arrangements for discharge – whether criteria to revoke are satisfied – discretion to revoke – decision under review affirmed
Bean and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission  AATA 940; 18/12/2014; Deputy President SD Hotop
Commonwealth employees – applicant served in Australian Army from 1981 to 1984 – applicant suffered recurrent skin infections, respiratory infections and related ailments during Army service – applicant tested for blood glucose but not for glucose tolerance during Army service – applicant contracted diabetes mellitus in 2004 – applicant’s diabetes mellitus not contributed to by failure to test for glucose tolerance or otherwise by Army service – applicant’s diabetes mellitus not a compensable injury – decision under review affirmed
Farrer and Comcare  AATA 943; 18/12/2014; Dr P McDermott RFD, Senior Member
Whether respondent liable for applicant’s neuropathy or chronic neuropathic pain – Further investigation of condition required – Decision set aside and remitted to respondent for re-determination, with costs incurred by applicant payable by the respondent.
Clare and Australian Community Pharmacy Authority  AATA 932; 15/12/2014; Senior Member BJ McCabe
Pharmacists – Interpretation of ‘town’ – Whether statutory exception can apply – Ambiguity – Consideration of extrinsic material – Decision under review affirmed.
Farag and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection  AATA 927; 12/12/2014; Deputy President JW Constance
Residence requirement – applicant an unlawful non-citizen for three days in the four years prior to his application – whether discretion should be exercised to treat the period as if the Applicant was not present in Australia as an unlawful non-citizen – whether administrative error – advice in grant of bridging visa incomplete and misleading – administrative error caused the Applicant to become an unlawful non-citizen – decision set aside and remitted
Konneh and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection  AATA 950; 18/12/2014; Senior Member CR Walsh
Citizenship by conferral – eligibility – general residence requirement – Applicant convicted of a number of offences relating to driving without a licence and providing false information to the police – Applicant’s offences “minor” under the Australian Citizenship Instructions – insufficient period has passed since Applicant’s most recent convictions – decision under review affirmed
Kumar and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection  AATA 944; 18/12/2014; Senior Member BJ McCabe
Applicant living in Fiji – Failure to meet general residence requirement – Discretion to treat periods of absence as time spent in Australia enlivened – No compelling reason to exercise the discretion – Decision under review affirmed.
Mohamed Marzook and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection  AATA 934; 16/12/2014; Senior Member RW Dunne
Application for citizenship – refusal by the delegate – general residence requirement not met – whether applicant was unlawful non-citizen – exercise of discretion – discretion not exercised – decision under review affirmed.
Nguyen and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection  AATA 945; 19/12/2014; Senior Member J Handley
Application for citizenship by conferral; applicant a citizen of Vietnam granted permanent residency of Australia – married in 1999 to an Australian citizen; both have subsequently lived in Vietnam save for short visits to Australia – applicant has spent 96 days in Australia in the period of 4 years before the application was made – applicant assists and supports her husband in his commercial and charitable work – whether applicant likely to reside in Australia or maintain a close and continuing association with Australia if the application were to be approved – decision affirmed
Waterman and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection  AATA 939; 18/12/2014; Senior Member N Isenberg
Eligibility – whether applicant is of good character – decision under review set aside and remitted
Bates and Comcare  AATA 931; 28/11/2014; Senior Member GD Friedman
Failure to comply with a direction of the Tribunal – expert assessment appointment – support person – multiple applications
Dennis and Secretary, Department of Employment  AATA 942; 18/12/2014; Senior Member BJ McCabe
Application for Extension Of Time – Considerations for exercise of the discretion – Merits of the application for review – Substantive application – Meaning of ‘spouse’ for purposes of relevant legislation – Applicant an ‘excluded employee’ under relevant scheme – Not reasonable in the circumstances to grant the extension of time – Application refused.
Queensland Nickel Pty Ltd and Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority  AATA 933; 16/12/2014; Deputy President PE Hack SC
Legal Professional Privilege – application to vary interim order permitting certain deletions of s 37 documents – whether privilege extends to subject matter of legal advice.
Queensland Nickel Pty Ltd and Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority  AATA 935; 8/12/2014; Deputy President PE Hack SC
Summons – Federal Court proceedings – direction that summons not be issued – direction that matter be held in abeyance if cannot be heard with Federal Court proceedings
Westbrook and Secretary, Department of Social Services  AATA 929; 28/11/2014; Senior Member NA Manetta
Jurisdiction – review of varied decision of respondent – no new issue raised on resumed hearing – proceedings dismissed as "frivolous or vexatious"
Angelevski and Secretary, Department of Social Services  AATA 947; 16/12/2014; Ms S Taglieri, Member
Age Pension eligibility; whether qualified residency requirements satisfied; failure to have 5 years continuous residence; decision to refuse claim for age pension was correct.
Confidential and Secretary, Department of Social Services  AATA 925; 12/12/2014; Mr C Ermert, Member
Disability Support Pension – whether conditions are fully diagnosed, treated and stabilised – whether impairments attract 20 impairment points – decision affirmed
El Cheikh and Secretary, Department of Social Services  AATA 936; 17/12/2014; Professor R McCallum AO, Member
Pensions – disability support pension – whether applicant’s impairment is of 20 points or more under the Impairment Tables – decision under review affirmed
Evans and Secretary, Department of Social Services  AATA 941; 18/12/2014; Dr M Denovan, Member
Pensions, benefits and allowances – Disability support pension – DSP – 20 points or more under the Impairment Tables – Cerebral vascular accident – CVA – Stroke – Decision set aside, substituted and remitted to the respondent.
Giamboi and Secretary, Department of Social Services  AATA 951; 16/12/2014; Senior Member CR Walsh
Overpayment of family tax benefit and schoolkids bonus – whether recovery of debt should be written off or waived – debt not attributable solely to an administrative error made by Centrelink – no “special circumstances” – decision under review affirmed
Keightley and Secretary, Department of Social Services  AATA 938; 17/12/2014; Senior Member BJ McCabe
Aged Care – Assets assessment – Inclusion of monies paid to applicant by daughter in 1989 – Classification of that transaction – Actual intention of the parties – Not a gift or loan – Not an express, implied or resulting trust – Applicant’s unjust enrichment does not alter characterisation of transaction – No basis for excluding funds from assets assessment – Decision under review affirmed.
Kooyoufas and Secretary, Department of Social Services  AATA 924; 12/12/2014; Senior Member E Fice
Disability support pension – assets test – income test – excess of assets and income – debt due to the Commonwealth – repayment of debt – waiver – cancellation of DSP – decision affirmed
Morton and Secretary, Department of Social Services  AATA 949; 16/12/2014; Senior Member CR Walsh
Unlimited portability period for disability support pension – none of applicant’s impairments (spinal disorder, lower limb deficiencies and shoulder and upper arm disorder) is a “severe impairment” – decision under review affirmed
Pettiford and Commissioner of Taxation  AATA 937; 5/12/2014; Deputy President IR Molloy
Capital gains tax – Objection to Commissioners calculation – No evidence provided by applicant proving incorrect calculation – Applicant is not displaced by calculation – Decision under review affirmed.
The Eight Modern Chinese Restaurant Pty Ltd and Australian Trade Commission  AATA 923; 12/12/2014; Deputy President SE Frost
Industry assistance – export market development grants – whether the new business is similar to the old business to such an extent that the new business should be treated as a continuation of the old business – decision under review affirmed